Halloween Candy Tier List: Best & Worst Picks [2023]

Here, We Are Going To Exclusively Rank Some Of The Best And Worst Halloween Candy.

Halloween is that time of the year when we allow ourselves to indulge in some treats, whether that be something common like candy or perhaps something old school like caramel apples. I’m not going to lie though, I love looking for new excuses to eat sweets, and Halloween is simply one more reason to indulge yourself.

But there are quite a few different types of candy out there that people associate with the event, and we wanted to rank which ones are worth getting and which ones aren’t. And in our Halloween Candy Tier List, we will assist you with making the right decision for yourself as well. So dive into the article and find out what is worth your time.


Key Points

  • In this article, I am going to rank the most popular Halloween candy based on taste.
  • There are a total of 15 entries on our list.
  • In higher tiers, you will find candy like M&Ms, Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups, Snickers, Sour Patch Kids, and Skittles.
  • Among the lower tiers, you can find Peanut Butter Kisses, Necco Wafers, Smarties, Milky Way, and Nerds.

Summary

In order to make things easier for you, I am going to rank all entries in the table below.

S RankA RankB RankC RankD Rank
• Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups
• M&Ms
• Snickers
• Skittles
• Sour Patch Kids
• Hershey Bar
• Kit Kat
• Twix
• Butterfinger
• Candy Corn
• Peanut Butter Kisses
• Necco Wafers
• Smarties
• Milky way
• Nerds

Learn more about each candy by reading further.

S Tier

HALLOWEEN CANDY TIER LIST
S Tier.

In the current category of our Ultimate Halloween Candy tier list, you will find candy that deserves to be in the number 1 spot, no matter what. Everyone loves to have these. 

Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups

Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups are a great treat to have on Halloween. The candy has been around since 1928, and it is still one of the best candies in existence today. It tastes delicious, has a good amount of protein for your body to absorb, and is simple yet tempting.

Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups are ranked number 1 out of all the other Halloween candies on the list because they’re so good! The combination between peanut butter and chocolate just works perfectly together to make an amazing treat that will satisfy anyone who eats them (or at least me).

M&Ms

M&Ms is a candy that is made of chocolate and a variety of other ingredients. The M&Ms candy was created by Forrest Mars, Sr. in 1941 and it has been our favorite since our old times because of its amazing taste. It deserves to be ranked in the S tier because of its great taste, which makes us want to eat more!

Snickers

Snickers is a chocolate bar with caramel and peanuts. It’s one of the most popular candies in America, and for good reason: it tastes great!

Snickers is also a pretty good Halloween candy. While some people love it because it’s satisfyingly sweet, others prefer more savory options like Twix bars or Kit Kats. Either way, this delicious treat will leave you feeling happy after eating it—and maybe even hungry again when your stomach starts growling!

Skittles

Skittles is one of the best Halloween candies. It’s a sugary, chewy, and colorful candy that tastes sweet and fresh. Skittles colors include orange, red, and yellow for your enjoyment on the spookiest time of year.

The best thing about skittles is how much fun you can have with them! The gummy candies are delicious as well as being really fun to eat. They’re also very colorful which makes them perfect for Halloween celebrations!

Sour Patch Kids

Sour Patch Kids are the best Halloween candy for kids because they taste like a treat that adults would enjoy too! The candy has been around since 1985 when it was introduced by the jingle “Sour Patch Kids are so sour!”

Sour Patch Kids are available in three different varieties: berry, lemon, lime, orange, and raspberry. The best part is that you can get all of these flavors at Walmart or Target stores.

A Tier

BEST PICKS
A Tier.

Now, coming toward the second category of the Best Halloween candy. here, I will rank some of the best Halloween candies. 

Hershey Bar

Hershey Bar is a chocolate bar. It is one of the best Halloween candies and should be given out to trick-or-treaters. The nice thing about the chocolate is that it melts so smoothly inside your mouth, which makes it taste even better than most entries on our Chocolate Tier List.

I love Hershey bars because they’re so easy to eat with my hands (or fingers) while trick-or-treating or just hanging out at home watching TV! In short, if you’re looking for an easy way to get kids excited about Halloween night then look no further than Hershey Bar – one of my favorite Halloween candies ever!

Kit Kat

Kit Kat is a two-in-one combination of wafers and chocolate, so it has creamy and crunchy goodness inside it. The taste of Kit Kat is amazing and so scrumptious that I will love to keep it with me rather than sharing it with my family members or friends on Halloween night.

Twix

Twix is a delicious wafer bar made of caramel and chocolate. It’s a great treat to have on hand during Halloween because it has both sweet and salty elements. The candy is also perfect for anyone who likes to snack as much as possible during the day (like me). Twix makes me feel like I’m eating something delicious without having to actually eat anything!

They may not be one of the oldest brands in the world of chocolate, but they’re still going strong due to their unique taste profile that’s just right for any occasion. Even if you’re trying out new foods at school or work tomorrow morning after trick-or-treating tonight!

Butterfinger

Now here is a candy bar made by none other than Nestle. It’s a peanut butter, caramel, and chocolate candy bar. It was first introduced in 1923 and has since become one of the most popular Halloween treats.

B Tier

LIKABLE PICKS
B Tier.

In the third category of the biggest Halloween candy tier list, I am going to place the likable choices. Let’s see if there is your choice in it or not. 

Candy Corn

Candy Corn is a likable Halloween candy. It’s got that nice crunch and smooth texture. However, the majority of people probably won’t rank it higher. However, it still feels good to have it. It’s just a tradition—like trick-or-treating!

Peanut Butter Kisses

Peanut Butter Kisses are a classic Halloween candy. These delicious peanut butter-flavored pieces of chocolate come in orange or black packaging, and they’re always a hit with kids.

They’re easy to eat, too! Just pop one in your mouth and let your tongue enjoy the taste of peanut butter without any messy sticky hands!

C Tier

BELOW-AVERAGE PICKS
C Tier.

In the C Tier I will be ranking the below-average category of candy.

Consider Reading: Pringles Tier List

Necco Wafers

They were first made in 1847, and they’re still popular today. While it’s not the best Halloween candy you can find, it’s also not your worst option either. If you want something that is an average choice for trick-or-treating or even just for snacking on at home with friends, Necco Wafers are an excellent choice!

D Tier

WORST PICKS
D Tier.

Lastly, you will find the worst picks in this category of the Halloween candy tier list. 

Smarties

Smarties are made of sugar and corn syrup, which is a very unhealthy ingredient. They’re also not good for your teeth or body. Despite being the worst candy on the list, it’s still a popular Halloween treat. However, if you’re going to eat them (which we hope you don’t), I recommend getting some dental floss to clean out your braces before eating any Smarties.

There are many more options available other than Smarties that you may enjoy on the holiday. However, if you have someone in your family who loves candy corn or M&Ms but hates Smarties (or vice versa), these two options will give them something sweet without feeling guilty about their choices!

Milky Way

Milky Way is a chocolate bar that was introduced in 1923. It’s made by Mars, and it has a caramel core, peanuts, and even a nougat. The candy is made in the USA, so you can feel confident about your purchase if you’re looking for American Halloween treats.

Ir in different flavors: original flavor, simply caramel, midnight dark, and seasonal caramel apple flavor. The first two options are delicious—and also pretty easy to find on store shelves.

Nerds

Nerds are sweet and sour. They were originally invented by Willy Wonka Candy Factory in 1883, but they’ve grown in popularity since then. Nerds are made from sugar, corn syrup, gelatin, and artificial flavors. It’s not worth trying these out on Halloween unless you’re into getting grossed out by candy that tastes like vomit or diarrhea—you’ll probably end up throwing up afterward!

Verdict

Some of the candy in our article is really bad because they don’t taste like anything at all. Moreover, they have a weird texture or flavor that makes them completely unappetizing. Other times it’s just an overall disappointment because maybe they were too sweet or didn’t have enough chocolate flavor. But then again we’ve got some pretty amazing options here as well! You can find some seriously amazing treats depending on what kind of mood you’re in when going out shopping for Halloween goodies this year. And, trust me when I say there will be plenty of choices available no matter where you live across America!

So hopefully our Ultimate Halloween candy tier list was helpful for you in figuring out which of these treats to get for the occasion, and which ones to avoid. If you have any other suggestions for us, we’d love to hearn them in the comments below.